Friday, March 16, 2012

A Few Thoughts on the Syracuse Win and the Aftermath

Syracuse demonstrated how to NOT make the cover of the NY Post

Syracuse survived against UNC Asheville yesterday, but today everyone across the country, and especially on sports talk radio, is still howling about the game - or more accurately howling about the officiating at the end of the game.

Let's get this right out of the way - as Brent Axe has articulated so eloquently, the officiating throughout the entire game was abysmal. While I can certainly understand why UNC Asheville was upset, there were missed calls on both sides that affected the outcome. There was the end of the first half fiasco when Triche was fouled before the shot clock expired, the phantom goaltending call that gave UNCA two points in the first half and a myriad of ticky tack fouls that shouldn't have been called against either team.

At the end of the day, if this game can spur the NCAA can do something to improve officiating, that will be a win. Granted I don't think it will happen, but it is clear something needs to be done.

However, everyone is still talking about the game today for two main reasons:

1) It was a 16 seed almost beating a one seed.

2) Other than the Wichita State - VCU game, it was a day that lacked a lot of drama and close games. In prior years, with upsets and fantastic finishes, people would still be talking, but not to this extent. However, yesterday the games weren't close and went mainly according to seed, so something like this is red meat for everyone who makes their living opining about sports.

What is ironic about the whole situation is the contrast to what  happened to Syracuse in last year's tournament. You remember that - when a missed call cost Syracuse a chance to beat Marquette. Then again, maybe you don't because the incident was barely reported on.  The common thread in both last year's situation and this year's is the fact that announcers working the games didn't know the rules of the college game.

Against Marquette, the missed over and back call against Jardine wasn't emphasized because the announcing team didn't know the rule and thought the call was correct. Against UNCA, Cheryl Miller's brother (who has no business working NCAA games) went nuts on the correctly applied lane violation call and got everyone all spun up.

Look, the officiating was bad, but the refs didn't steal this for UNC Asheville. They didn't help them, but that's life. So Eddie Biedenbach claiming the better team didn't win is just an emotional coach after a tough loss. Again, I get why he said it, but he's wrong.  At the end of the day if Syracuse makes a deep run, no one will remember this game. If they get bounced early, it will live in infamy.

A couple of thoughts on the game

- Syracuse played awful. Scoop, Kris Joseph and CJ Fair have all be MIA for the last 4 games. I have no idea how they turn it around.

- Kansas State should be licking its chops right now.

- How do you come out flat for a game like this?

- Syracuse should have pressed and tried to change tempo. Instead Boeheim sat in the zone and let Asheville hang around. The Orange had twice as many athletes but Boeheim's style let a lesser opponent hang around.  The only answer to why is that JB is stubborn. Sometimes that stubbornness works in his favor, sometimes it does not. Yesterday it did not.

- Besides if you press Baye Keita can actually be useful protecting the rim at the back end of the press.

- That was the least amount of fun I've had watching a game this year - and it's not even close.

- Boeheim escalating a fight with Arne Duncan is Boeheim being Boeheim at this point. He can't NOT be confrontational. The guy probably kills flies with a shotgun.

Syracuse - Kansas State is at 12:15 on St. Patrick's Day. By 2:15 you'll know if you're drinking because you're happy or drinking because you're sad. Right now I have no idea what it will be.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Cuse apologist

Russianator said...

Good addition anonymous, your articulation of the issue makes this blog better.

The officials were bad - they were bad both ways.

And yes, we are syracuse fans, so that's the perspective we are coming from.

Anonymous said...

Great Post Neph!-It was ugly but a win is a win. The thing that irks me is that the talking heads act like SU is the only team that gets calls. Duke and UNC get calls all of the time. The main problem was that Joseph and Jardine did not show up in the 1st half. CJ seems to have lost his jumper. Anyway, bring on the Wildcats!
Take care, Uncle Dave

johnvroom said...

Another great article r-nater, I am sick to death of the bloggers talking about a conspiracy (the fix being in). The problem was simply poor officiating! Was it any worse than a Big East game, no it was very similar.... I have been more ticked off at Big East officiating but this was close. From SU's perspective this officiating took the joy from an earned win, from UNC-A perspective it robbed them of the opportunity to win... classic lose-lose.

Mizzu just lost to Norfolk St (local team for me) and everyone is applauding the effort of NSU not the refs incompitence... that is what college basketball is all about